Where Do Returned Items Go? What Six Years Reselling Costco and Amazon Returns Taught Me
Founder, OpenBoxFox
Returns that a store can't put back on the shelf are usually sold in bulk, by the pallet or the truckload, to liquidation retailers that inspect, grade and resell them. From 2017 to 2023 I was the web developer at one of those retailers, Big Box Outlet Store in British Columbia, and I also managed its e-commerce team. We opened about 10 pallets of returns a week. Most of what was inside worked fine.
How returns get from the store to a reseller
Big retailers sell returns and overstock they can't restock to liquidators, through their own auctions or through platforms like B-Stock. Big Box Outlet Store is a family-owned liquidation retailer headquartered in Abbotsford, and Costco is its biggest supplier, according to a 2023 interview with Retail Insider. When I was there, our stock came from Amazon, Costco, Walmart and other vendors on contracts that let the company buy returns at a deep discount. Some of it was overstock: products a store couldn't sell fast enough.
It arrived as pallets and truckloads, and we sold it in our stores and online. My team grew from about 3 people to about 10. I did the web development, set up the systems we sold through, wrote the procedures for photographing, grading and pricing every item, and I also ran shipping for the online orders, which went mostly around BC and across Canada.
What's actually inside a returns pallet
Anything a big store sells could turn up. Lego was one of our biggest sellers, along with electronics like laptops and iPhones. The condition varied as much as the products, and the reason for the return usually explained it. Unwanted Christmas gifts and bounced deliveries tended to arrive in new condition. Old models that people returned in the box of the newer version they had bought usually still worked, but they were older and worn. Some returns were unusable, and we threw them out or kept them for parts. Our guide to what open box means has the full list of return reasons we saw.
How much was waste? Roughly 10% of what came in from Walmart, Amazon, Costco and the others. The vendors usually filter out the obviously unusable items before the bins ship, so the rest could usually be resold.
How we graded and priced every item
We inspected every item by hand, photographed it to show its real condition and gave it a grade from A (new) to D (as is, for parts). The grade alone set the discount. Even D-grade items sold, at a very deep discount, to people who wanted them for parts. Our condition grades guide has the full scale with our prices and lines it up with Amazon's and Best Buy's grade names.
The surprise: two pallets of hair clippers
We had a pallet of Remington electric hair clippers that barely sold before COVID. When COVID closed hair salons, about two pallets of clippers sold out within a couple of weeks. My guess is that people with no stylist to go to started cutting hair at home.
What I'd tell anyone buying open box
Start with the worn grade. The C grade, for items that work but show wear, is where I saw the best value. Buy from a seller that inspects its stock and takes returns, and use the item hard while you can still send it back. My checklist and the way I vet sellers are in our open-box safety guide.
Why I started OpenBoxFox
Working with returns showed me how much good product goes into the resale system, and how hard it is to find. Most big retailers have a clearance or returns section, but finding a specific open-box or refurbished item means searching Google, then searching each store, and sometimes it isn't there. OpenBoxFox collects those listings from reputable stores in one place. You save the time of going site to site, you get the discount, and a working product stays out of the trash.
You can browse the current US open-box deals or see this month's average discounts in the Open-Box Price Index.
Frequently asked questions
Where do Costco and Amazon returns go?
Items that can't go back on the shelf are often sold in bulk to liquidators, by the pallet or truckload, through the retailer's own auctions or platforms like B-Stock. Liquidation retailers then inspect, grade and resell them in stores and online.
Are returned items in good condition?
Mostly. In the returns I handled, roughly 10% was waste. Many returns were unwanted gifts or bounced deliveries in new condition, and others showed light or visible wear but worked.
What happens to returns that don't work?
In the returns I handled, some were thrown out or kept for parts. Others were graded as is and sold at a very deep discount to people who wanted them for parts.
Related reading
- Open-box condition grades explained
- What does open box mean?
- Is it safe to buy open box?
- About Sig Kappel
This article is based on the author's own experience managing the online department at Big Box Outlet Store from 2017 to 2023. Company background (family-owned, Abbotsford headquarters, Costco as biggest supplier) is from Retail Insider's January 2023 interview. Researched and drafted with AI assistance and checked by Sig Kappel. How we write our guides. OpenBoxFox earns affiliate commissions on some links: see our affiliate disclosure.